Friday, February 11, 2011

Opening Day Lineup Predictions: The Competition

We're just a weekend away from pitchers and catchers reporting to Viera for Spring Training 2011. This is it, folks. The season is finally upon us, and we couldn't be more excited. With just a few short weeks left, we've decided to put our predictions down on (virtual) paper as an inter-Capitol Baseball competition. Have your own opinion? Sound off in the comments.

Lineup

Position in Batting Order

Joe

Mac

1.

Nyjer Morgan

Nyjer Morgan

2.

Ian Desmond

Ian Desmond

3.

Ryan Zimmerman

Ryan Zimmerman

4.

Adam LaRoche

Jayson Werth

5.

Jayson Werth

Adam LaRoche

6.

Roger Bernadina

Roger Bernadina

7.

Danny Espinosa

Danny Espinosa

8.

Pudge Rodriguez

Pudge Rodriguez

9.

Livan Hernandez

Livan Hernandez

Rotation


Rotation Spot

Joe

Mac

Opening Day (1.)

Livan Hernandez

Livan Hernandez

2.

John Lannan

Jordan Zimmermann

3.

Jordan Zimmermann

John Lannan

4.

Jason Marquis

Jason Marquis

5.

Tom Gorzelanny

Yunesky Maya

Notes: Mac and I had the exact same lineup and almost the same rotation, so I decided to tweak mine a bit just for fun. Who knows what'll happen?

Show us your Opening Day lineup/predictions in the Comments section!

9 comments:

  1. I agree with most of your lineup: Here is my prediction:

    Lineup:

    1. Morgan
    2. Desmond
    3. Zimmerman
    4. LaRoche (have to have the lefy bat here)
    5. Werth
    6. Morse
    7. Espinosa
    8. Pudge
    9. Livo

    Rotation:
    1. Livo
    2. Zimmermann (need a change of pace guy after Livo)
    3. Marquis
    4. Lannan
    5. Gorzelanny

    ReplyDelete
  2. I don't see any problem with your lineup, Harper_ROY. I don't see back to back lefties in the rotation with Lannan and Gorzelanny, though. I could see JZimm 2nd, but then Lannan would have to be 3 and Gorzelanny 5, IMHO.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I agree with Joe's lineup exactly; LaRoche bats 4th to go R-L-R-L. I cannot for the life of me figure out why Bernadina is the presumed starter over Morse right now; Morse patently out hit him last year, shows more power, and is an athletic former infielder who should be fine in left. But for whatever reason he's the presumed starter.

    Rotation: Agree with Joe again. Gorzelanny is out of options and we aren't paying him $2M plus the prospects we gave up to have him be a middle reliever. Maya is optioned to AAA to start and replaces the first injured starter.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Morgan CF
    Desmond SS
    Zimmerman 3B
    Werth RF
    LaRoche 1B
    Rodriguez C
    Bernadina LF
    Espinosa 2B
    Hernandez P

    1. Hernandez
    2. Marquis
    3. Gorzelanny
    4. Zimmermann
    5. Lannan

    I've always liked Lannan's craftiness, but if his guile falters even a little, he could be surpassed by Maya or others.

    Another prediction is member of starting lineup who will be the first to depart the starting lineup, whether by injury, trade, benching, or whatever. My money, regrettably, is on Morgan.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I agree that Joe's is better, I would much rather have LaRoche hitting 4th to split up the righties. But I am going based on what I THINK it will be, Riggs has never really bothered with spliting up lefty-righty batters in the lineup.

    With that in mind, he does play batter-pitcher splits pretty frequently, and considering we are playing the Braves on Opening Day... Their Opening Day starter will most likely be Tim Hudson, a righty, and if not him it will be Tommy Hanson, also a righty. So, with those factors, it stands to reason that, playing the matchups, the left-handed hitting Bernadina would start over the right-handed hitting Morse.

    Maya is a shot in the dark, I'm thinking that his insanely impressive Winter League performance (pitcher of the year) carries over to Spring Training, leaving riggs no choice but to put him in the rotation.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Lineup:

    1 Espinoza 4
    2 Desmond 6
    3 Zimmerman 5
    4 Werth 9
    5 Laroche 3
    6 Ankiel 7
    7 Bernadina 8
    8 Rodriquez 2
    9 Zimmermann 1

    Rotation

    Zimmerman
    Hernandez
    Lannan
    Gorzelany
    Maya

    marquis and morgan are done...perhaps im ahead of my time...but thats my lineup

    ReplyDelete
  7. ps yes i know thats 3 lefties in a row 5-6-7...but heres where the beauty lies...the other teams brings in their loogy...BAM MICHAEL MORSE OFF THE BENCH FOR ANKIEL... its a trap!

    ReplyDelete
  8. Power pitchers first ... after opening day. Remember,its likely Zimmermann, Gorzelanny and perhaps Detwiler will have strong April/May pitching appearances. Then, there's the soft-tossing rubber armed Livo who might serve the team best for the bullpen in long relief / spot start capacity.

    1. Zimmermann
    2. Gorzelanny
    3. Maya
    4. Lannan/Detwiler
    5. Marquis/Livo

    Lannan and Marquis look like tradable commodities if the top 3 pan out. Lefty Tom Milone is very close and Livo is probably a better choice at #5 than Marquis this year. I expect the rotation to change after Memorial Day. Mock is a dark horse but both he and Detwiler (and Wang) must prove they have their velocity back.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Rotation looks good to me. I think Morgan's gonna have a killer year if he can avoid those "knucklehead" outbursts. While we're getting ready for the season, check out getting HD for FREE for your system. I work for DISH and now have HD Free for Life. Now I'll get all my Rockies games in HD, along with about 200 other channels...For FREE!!! Take a look at DISHNetwork.com and see how!!

    ReplyDelete